• CSC Home Page
  • Order Book
  • Table of Contents
  • Preface
  • Endorsements
  • Part I: Scientific Case for Creation
    • Life Sciences
    • Astronomical and Physical Sciences
    • Earth Sciences
    • References and Notes
  • Part II: Fountains of the Great Deep
    • The Hydroplate Theory: An Overview
    • The Origin of Ocean Trenches
    • Liquefaction: The Origin of Strata and Layered Fossils
    • The Origin of the Grand Canyon
    • The Origin of Limestone
    • Frozen Mammoths
    • The Origin of Comets
    • The Origin of Asteroids and Meteoroids
  • Part III: Frequently Asked Questions
  • Technical Notes
  • Index

  • Previous Page
  • Next Page

This is the online edition of In the Beginning: Compelling Evidence for Creation and the Flood
(8th Edition) by Dr. Walt Brown. The online version of the book is designed to be read online.
The 7th Edition (PDF version or hardbound print version) may be ordered.
Copyright © 1995–2008, Center for Scientific Creation. All rights reserved.

Click here to order the hardbound print edition of this online book.

[ The Fountains of the Great Deep > Frozen Mammoths > Details Relating to the Mild Ice Age Theory ]

Details Relating to the Mild Ice Age Theory

79. circlered.jpg Image ThumbnailAbundant Food, circlered.jpg Image ThumbnailWarm Climate, circleyellow.jpg Image ThumbnailMulti-Continental. Same as item 70.

Without explaining how, Michael Oard,137 the author of this theory, concludes that Siberia and Alaska must have had “mild winters” and little or no permafrost, because those normally frigid lands contain carcasses, abundant bones, large trees in growth positions, and insects and other animals that live in warmer climates.166 “Mild winters,” a phrase Oard uses often, would still be deadly winters in Siberia and Alaska. Sustained and unseasonably warm winter days and nights are required—without a single exception in 700 years. Are “mild winters” reasonable at those high latitudes during the peak of the Ice Age?

How does food grow in a vast, barren wilderness during the long, dark winter? Each of the millions of mammoths required hundreds of pounds of suitable vegetation daily. Today’s bog vegetation is unsuitable and insufficient. Why didn’t earlier, milder dust storms—as during America’s Dust Bowl Era—destroy the mammoth’s food supply? Also, Oard’s logic avoids the catastrophic implications seen across a 3,000-mile stretch of three continents. [See “Geographical Extent” on page 238.]

80. circlered.jpg Image ThumbnailYedomas and Loess. Dust and snow storms would not deposit the vast amount of carbon and organic matter found in yedomas, especially inside the Arctic Circle during the Ice Age. Also, loess is qualitatively different from storm generated dust. Loess particles are angular, giving them the ability to form vertical surfaces such as in cliffs, loess dwellings, and furniture. [See Figure 139 on page 241.] Most dust particles are rounded by years of erosion. What was the source of so much loess?

81. circleyellow.jpg Image ThumbnailRock Ice.  Same as item 73.

82. circleyellow.jpg Image ThumbnailFrozen Muck.  This theory does not explain why muck has been found at 4,000-foot depths. If even a few hundred of feet of blowing dust accumulated in some places, that dust would have prevented the erosion of more dust directly below. Why would so much vegetation be mixed in the blowing dust?

83. circlered.jpg Image ThumbnailSudden Freezing.  Snow and dust are excellent insulators, because they trap so much air. Large animals suddenly buried in thick layers of snow and dust would be insulated from the cold atmosphere. Their residual body heat would promote decay, delay freezing, and hinder preservation. [See Hoyle’s comments on page 250.]

84. circleyellow.jpg Image ThumbnailSuffocation.  If large animals died in sudden snow or dust storms, it would be from exposure and starvation, not suffocation.

85. circlered.jpg Image Thumbnail-150°F.  Sudden storms which drop temperatures to -150°F are unheard of, even in Antarctica. [To understand why, see “Why Did It Get So Cold So Quickly?” on page 239.] If temperatures during the Ice Age were that severe, why didn’t the mammoths and other temperate animals buried next to them die centuries earlier by starvation or in merely -50°F temperatures?

According to this theory, the greatest temperature differences between oceans and continents would have been soon after the flood, not 700 years later, after the oceans had cooled. Storm intensities would have diminished during those 700 years. Had mammoths, and the other temperate animals found with them, attempted to migrate from the “mountains of Ararat” to their present graveyards, they should have died before they reached their destination and before 700 years had passed—long before the mammoth population increased to 10 million.

86. circleyellow.jpg Image ThumbnailLarge Animals.  Same as item 77.

87. circleyellow.jpg Image ThumbnailSummer-Fall Deaths.  Oard states that most of the known times of deaths were in the late summer or early fall, even though the most dangerous season in Siberia and Alaska is winter, especially during the Ice Age.

88. circleyellow.jpg Image ThumbnailVertical Compression.Burial in a dust storm should not produce—before or soon after death—the vertical compression, crushing, and bleeding found in Berezovka.

89. circlered.jpg Image ThumbnailOther/Migration to North America.  How did mammoths migrate from Siberia to North America? Oard argues that the maximum volume of ice stored on the continents during the Ice Age was much less than most experts estimate. (Their estimates, if correct, would lower today’s sea level 300–400 feet, enough to open up a wide land bridge at the Bering Strait.)167 Oard acknowledges the difficulty he has in explaining the migration,168 but believes that at the peak of the mild Ice Age, a narrow land bridge briefly opened.169 At another point, he claims that “... mammoths and other animals had thrived and migrated over the entire Northern Hemisphere at the beginning of the Ice Age.”170 [my emphasis] (The hydroplate theory and simple geometry explain why sea level following the flood was several miles lower, making migrations between Asia and the Americas possible for a few centuries and the land bridge at the Bering Strait more than 1,000 miles wide.)

90. circlered.jpg Image ThumbnailOther/Deep Freezing. If the present cold temperatures of Siberia and Alaska began after a global flood about 5,000 years ago, trees and soil 1,900 feet below the earth’s surface would not have had time to freeze, and the buried trees should have decayed. However, if freezing and burial began at the onset of the flood, as explained by the hydroplate theory, the deep, quickly frozen wood and soil, described on page 236, would be explained.

91. circleyellow.jpg Image ThumbnailOther/Cold Winds. This theory claims that a warm Arctic Ocean would produce warm winds that would make Siberia and Alaska tolerable. Actually, a warm Arctic Ocean would have the opposite effect. Strong updrafts over the Arctic Ocean would pull cold air from the surrounding continents in over coastal regions.

92. circleyellow.jpg Image ThumbnailOther/Population Increase.  It is doubtful that mammoths and their young migrated 4,500 miles to Siberia during the Ice Age and increased their numbers to 10 million—all in just 700 years. Where have such large animals ever increased their numbers that much and that quickly, even in a tranquil environment? Extrapolating population growth rates and appealing to geometric progressions overlooks the requirements for abundant food, liquid water, and temperate habitats. Obviously, photosynthesis does not occur inside the Arctic Circle in the dead of winter, Ice Age or no Ice Age.

  • Previous Page
  • Next Page

This site is best viewed with a screen resolution of 1024 x 768 (XGA) or higher and a browser that supports cascading style sheets.
We have tested the site in Internet Explorer (Win), Netscape (Win), Safari (Mac), and Firefox (Mac and Win).
Please let us know if you have any suggestions or find any problems with the site.

Updated on Wednesday, July 23
Copyright © 1995–2008
Center for Scientific Creation
http://www.creationscience.com

(602) 955-7663